Table of Content
divisibility
Open AccessArticleWhen does the sum of an arithmetic progression divide its odd power sums?
Mohammed Aassila
Annals of Communications in Mathematics 2026,
9(4),
6
DOI: https://doi.org/10.62072/acm.2026.09053
Abstract:Let \( a_1,\ldots,a_n \) be an integer arithmetic progression with common difference \( d \) and sum \( S \), and let \( p \) be odd. It is classical that \( 1+2+\cdots+n \) divides \( 1^p+2^p+\cdots+n^p \), and that \( S \) divides \( \sum a_i^3 \) for every arithmetic progression; but \( S \) need not divide \( \sum a_i^5 \) (for instance, \( 9 \nmid 2^5+3^5+4^5 \)). We determine, for odd \( p \geq 3 \), the exact denominator of \( \sum a_i^p/S \): it is the product of the odd primes \( q \) with \( q \mid n \), \( q \mid a_1+a_n \), \( q \nmid d \), \( (q-1) \mid (p-1) \), and \( q \nmid p \). Consequently, \( S \mid \sum a_i^p \) for every integer progression of length \( n \) if and only if every prime dividing \( \gcd(n,D_{p-1}) \) divides \( 2p \), where \( D_{p-1} \) is the denominator of the Bernoulli number \( B_{p-1} \); equivalently, \( n^2 \mid 1^p+3^p+\cdots+(2n-1)^p \). The exponents \( p \) for which \( S \mid \sum a_i^p \) for all progressions of all lengths are exactly the odd \( p \) with \( D_{p-1} \mid 2p \); the only prime among them is \( 3 \); nevertheless there are infinitely many. As secondary results we record the centred expansion of \( \sum a_i^p \), the cubic identity \( \sum a_i^3 = S\left(a_1a_n+\binom{n}{2}d^2\right) \) for every length \( n \), the determination of all progressions satisfying Nicomachus’ identity \( \sum a_i^3 = S^2 \), and a self-contained proof of the even-exponent analogue, which is a consequence of a theorem of Moree.




